Questions of interest

Posted by [Zenith John] on Friday, December 31, 2021
Last Modified on Friday, December 9, 2022

[2021-12-31 Fri 14:25] This page serves as a list of some problems I care about with some additional remarks. For most papers referenced, I only read the reviews or abstracts.

Donaldson-Thomas type theory for CY 4-folds

The idea of Donaldson-Thomas theory originated in [1], where Donaldson and Thomas suggested some gauge-theoretic analog of 3 dimensional Chern-Simons theory and 4 dimensional Donaldson theory to higher dimensional manifolds, for example Calabi-Yau 3-fold, \(G_{2}\) manifold and \(Spin(7)\) manifold (also higher dimesional CY varieties). For a long time, only CY3 case is established in [2] and widely studied and other 2 cases remains obscure.

By the injection \(SU(4) \to Spin(7)\), the CY 4-fold can be viewed as special \(Spin(7)\) manifold. However, the problem is the obstruction theory has more than two terms and methods of [3] can not be applied. With a lot of work in derived algebraic geometry, including [47], the Donaldson-Thomas type invariants in CY 4-folds were established in [8] (special case) and [9] (general case) using analytic methods. More recently, algebraic virtual class is obtained in [10]. Many results for CY3 can be transported to CY4 case, including some cases of MNOP conjectures (also in [8]), the dimension zero DT generating seris in [11]. the DT/PT correspondence in [12], the relation to Gopakumar-Vafa invariants in [1316] and maybe a lot more. It is then a natural question, whether Donaldson-Thomas invariants can be generalized to even higher dimensions, since we are not using special holonomy in construction. For some work in this direction, the counting of dimension zero subschemes is studied in [17]. As a reminder, Gromov-Witten theory is well defined for varieties of arbitrary dimension.

On the other hand, Donaldson-Thomas type sheaf counting theory is very flexible and has many generalizations. For example, via spectral equivalence, the Vafa-Witten theory, a gauge-theoretic invariants for 4-manifolds, on projective algebraic surfaces can be formulated as a special sheaf counting theory on local CY3 as in [18,19]. The similiar ideas can be used to study Kapustin-Witten theory [20] which may be formulated as a sheaf-couting theory on local CY4. The first step of which is [21], where some special CY4 was considered. Also, recently, some surface couting theory on CY4 was constructed in [22].

Categorification of Donaldson-Thomas Theory

[2021-12-31 Fri 15:26] The Calabi-Yau 3-fold case is defined by algebraic methods of [3] in [2]. Since then a lot of study in DT theory emerges. Categorification of Donaldson-Thomas theory is one of important problems in Donaldson-Thomas theory. The physicists view Donaldson-Thomas invariants as dimension of BPS states. Mathematically, the problem is raised in [23] and [24] in somehow different manner.

The approach in [23] is to defined Donaldson-Thomas invariants in motivic rings. By taking the Euler characteristic, the motivic invariants descents to numerical Donaldson-Thomas invariants. This idea has been applied in [25] to prove PT/DT correspondence. Again in confiold case [26], the motivic refinement matches refined topological vertex defined in [27] as original DT theory matches topological vertex. In [28], the result of dimension zero numerical DT invariants was recovered.

The approach in [24] is to define some perverse sheaves and realized the numerical ones as Euler characteristics again. This approach is later generalized to Saito’s mixed hodge module theory as mentioned in [28]. These perverse sheaves techniques together with critical loci was used to defined Gopakumar-Vafa invariants in [29]. A good survey of these development is [30]. Also, the categorifation of Donaldson-Thomas theory via monodromic mixed Hodge modules provides the proof of new results in quantum cluster algebra [31] and quantum enveloping algebras [32].

More recently, Toda suggest some new approaches in categorification based on derived algebraic geometry. In a seris of paper by [3335], he define and study some version of category of moduli spaces relating to Donaldson-Thomas theory. The numerical invariants are Euler characteristic of periodic cyclic homology of the category. Further properties are studied in [3638]. The categorical construction brings much of the results and ideas of noncommutative algebraic geometry to Donaldson-Thomas theory and recovers many classical results from a different point of view.

Donaldson-Thomas theory and Bridgeland stability

As Donaldson-Thomas theory counts (semi)stable sheaves, the notation of stability is important in the theory. [24] study the wall crossing phenomenon when changing stability condition for abelian category of coherent sheaves. A more ambitious proposal by [23] replace the abelian category by triangulated category, and Gieseker or \(\mu\)-stability by Bridgeland stability introduced in [39]. The derived category of coherent sheaves can be replaced by Calabi-Yau categories, allowing fruitful interactions with many areas, including representation of quivers in [32] and quantum cluster algebras in [31]. Its relation with mirror symmetry and wall-crossing formula was considered in [40]. More recently, Bridgeland suggesting a construction of \(\tau\) functions, a series of important functions in mathematical physics, and Joyce structrure, an analog of Frobenius structure, on stability space from Donaldson-Thomas theory of Calabi-Yau categories in [4143], showing their integrable systematic nature.

The study of Bridgeland stability is also active. The construction of Bridgeland stability condition on derived category of coherent sheaves is a very challenging problem. The elliptic curve case is studied in [44] and K3 surface in [45] by tilting the heart. In [46], authors suggested a double-tilting methods to construct Bridgeland stability condition on 3-folds based on generalized Bogomolov-Gieseker inequality. Though the latter inequality was wrong [47], the idea is used to successfully construct the stability condition for 3-folds in various cases, including abelian threefolds in [48], some Fano threefolds in [49], quintic threefold in [50]. A remarkable property of Bridgeland stability is that the stability space is local homeomorphic to the complex linear space generated by numerical Grothendieck group of the category, and therefore admits a complex manifold structure. The study of this space has applications to moduli of sheaves [51], autoequivalence of derived category of coherent sheaves [52], Donaldson-Thomas invariants [53] and Reid-type theorem [54]. We can also construct the moduli space of Bridgeland (semi)stable objects [55], which shares similar properties of moduli space of Gieseker (semi)stable objects. More recently, in [56] the stability in families is studied to prove the deformation invariance of Donaldson-Thomas theory of Bridgeland stable objects in Calabi-Yau threefolds and to provide a new method for constructing stability condition on threefolds.

Via homological mirror symmetry, the derived category of coherent sheaves on CY3 is equivalent to the Fukaya category of its mirror. These ideas inspire the research of finding stability condition on Fukaya categories and already generate some interesting geometric applications in [5759].

References

[2021-12-31 Fri 15:03] The references are auto generated. Due to incompatibility between biblatex and html, there may be some errors. Sorry for possible misunderstanding.

[1]
Donaldson, S K and Thomas, R P (1998 ). Gauge theory in higher dimensions. The geometric universe (oxford, 1996). 31–47
[2]
Thomas, R P (2000 ). A holomorphic Casson invariant for Calabi-Yau 3-folds, and bundles on \$K3\$ fibrations. Journal of differential geometry. Lehigh University. 54 367–438
[3]
Behrend, K and Fantechi, B (1997 ). The intrinsic normal cone. Inventiones mathematicae. 128 45–88
[4]
Lurie, J (2004 ). Derived algebraic geometry. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
[5]
Toen, B and Vezzosi, G (2006 ). Homotopical Algebraic Geometry II: Geometric stacks and applications. Arxiv:math/0404373. https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0404373
[6]
Pantev, T, Toën, B, Vaquié, M and Vezzosi, G (2013 ). Shifted symplectic structures. Publications mathématiques de l’ihés. 117 271–328
[7]
Brav, C, Bussi, V and Joyce, D (2019 ). A Darboux theorem for derived schemes with shifted symplectic structure. Journal of the american mathematical society. 32 399–443
[8]
Cao, Y and Leung, N C (2015 ). Donaldson-Thomas theory for Calabi-Yau 4-folds. Arxiv:1407.7659 [math]. https://arxiv.org/abs/1407.7659
[9]
Borisov, D and Joyce, D (2017 ). Virtual fundamental classes for moduli spaces of sheaves on CalabiYau four-folds. Geometry & topology. Mathematical Sciences Publishers. 21 3231–311
[10]
Oh, J and Thomas, R P (2021 ). Counting sheaves on Calabi-Yau 4-folds, I. Arxiv:2009.05542 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.05542
[11]
Cao, Y and Kool, M (2018 ). Zero-dimensional DonaldsonThomas invariants of CalabiYau 4-folds. Advances in mathematics. 338 601–48
[12]
Cao, Y and Kool, M (2020 ). Curve counting and DT/PT correspondence for Calabi-Yau 4-folds. Advances in mathematics. 375 107371
[13]
Cao, Y, Maulik, D and Toda, Y (2021 ). Stable pairs and GopakumarVafa type invariants for CalabiYau 4-folds. Journal of the european mathematical society. 24 527–81
[14]
Cao, Y, Maulik, D and Toda, Y (2018 ). Genus zero GopakumarVafa type invariants for CalabiYau 4-folds. Advances in mathematics. 338 41–92
[15]
Cao, Y, Oberdieck, G and Toda, Y (2022 ). Gopakumar-Vafa type invariants of holomorphic symplectic 4-folds. Arxiv:2201.10878 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.10878
[16]
Cao, Y, Oberdieck, G and Toda, Y (2022 ). Stable pairs and Gopakumar-Vafa type invariants on holomorphic symplectic 4-folds. Arxiv:2201.11540 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.11540
[17]
Cao, Y and Kool, M (2019 ). Counting zero-dimensional subschemes in higher dimensions. Journal of geometry and physics. 136 119–37
[18]
Tanaka, Y and Thomas, R (2020 ). Vafa-Witten invariants for projective surfaces I: Stable case. Journal of algebraic geometry. 29 603–68
[19]
Tanaka, Y and Thomas, R P (2017 ). VafaWitten invariants for projective surfaces II: Semistable case. Pure and applied mathematics quarterly. International Press of Boston. 13 517–62
[20]
Kapustin, A and Witten, E (2007 ). Electric-magnetic duality and the geometric Langlands program. Communications in number theory and physics. International Press of Boston. 1 1–236
[21]
Diaconescu, D-E, Sheshmani, A and Yau, S-T (2020 ). Atiyah class and sheaf counting on local Calabi Yau fourfolds. Advances in mathematics. 368 107132
[22]
Bae, Y, Kool, M and Park, H (2022 ). Counting surfaces on Calabi-Yau 4-folds I: Foundations. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.09474
[23]
Kontsevich, M and Soibelman, Y (2008 ). Stability structures, motivic Donaldson-Thomas invariants and cluster transformations. Arxiv:0811.2435 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/0811.2435
[24]
Joyce, D and Song, Y (2012 ). A Theory of Generalized DonaldsonThomas Invariants. American Mathematical Society
[25]
Bridgeland, T (2011 ). Hall algebras and curve-counting invariants. Journal of the american mathematical society. 24 969–98
[26]
Morrison, A, Mozgovoy, S, Nagao, K and Szendrői, B (2012 ). Motivic DonaldsonThomas invariants of the conifold and the refined topological vertex. Advances in mathematics. 230 2065–93
[27]
Dimofte, T and Gukov, S (2009 ). Refined, Motivic, and Quantum. Letters in mathematical physics. 91 1
[28]
Behrend, K, Bryan, J and Szendrői, B (2013 ). Motivic degree zero DonaldsonThomas invariants. Inventiones mathematicae. 192 111–60
[29]
Maulik, D and Toda, Y (2018 ). GopakumarVafa invariants via vanishing cycles. Inventiones mathematicae. 213 1017–97
[30]
Szendroi, B (2015 ). Cohomological Donaldson-Thomas theory
[31]
Davison, B (2018 ). Positivity for quantum cluster algebras. Annals of mathematics. Annals of Mathematics. 187 157–219
[32]
Davison, B and Meinhardt, S (2020 ). Cohomological DonaldsonThomas theory of a quiver with potential and quantum enveloping algebras. Inventiones mathematicae. 221 777–871
[33]
Toda, Y (2021 ). Categorical Donaldson-Thomas theory for local surfaces. Arxiv:1907.09076 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.09076
[34]
Toda, Y (2021 ). Categorical wall-crossing formula for Donaldson-Thomas theory on the resolved conifold. Arxiv:2109.07064 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.07064
[35]
Toda, Y (2021 ). Semiorthogonal decompositions for categorical Donaldson-Thomas theory via \$Theta\$-stratifications. Arxiv:2106.05496 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/2106.05496
[36]
P\ adurariu, T and Toda, Y (2022 ). Categorical and K-theoretic Donaldson-Thomas theory of \$ mathbb\\C\\\^3\$ (part I). arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.01899
[37]
P\ adurariu, T and Toda, Y (2022 ). Categorical and K-theoretic Donaldson-Thomas theory of \$ mathbb\\C\\\^3\$ (part II). arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.05920
[38]
P\ adurariu, T and Toda, Y (2022 ). The categorical DT/PT correspondence and quasi-BPS categories for local surfaces. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.12182
[39]
Bridgeland, T (2007 ). Stability conditions on triangulated categories. Annals of mathematics. 166 317–45
[40]
Kontsevich, M and Soibelman, Y (2014 ). Wall-Crossing Structures in DonaldsonThomas Invariants, Integrable Systems and Mirror Symmetry. Homological Mirror Symmetry and Tropical Geometry. Springer International Publishing, Cham. 197–308
[41]
Bridgeland, T (2020 ). Geometry from Donaldson-Thomas invariants. Arxiv:1912.06504 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/1912.06504
[42]
Bridgeland, T (2020 ). Riemann-Hilbert problems for the resolved conifold. Arxiv:1703.02776 [hep-th]. https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.02776
[43]
Bridgeland, T (2019 ). RiemannHilbert problems from DonaldsonThomas theory. Inventiones mathematicae. 216 69–124
[44]
Bridgeland, T (2006 ). Stability Conditions on a Non-Compact Calabi-Yau Threefold. Communications in mathematical physics. 266 715–33
[45]
Bridgeland, T (2008 ). Stability conditions on K3 surfaces. Duke mathematical journal. Duke University Press. 141 241–91
[46]
Bayer, A, Macrì, E and Toda, Y (2014 ). Bridgeland stability conditions on threefolds I: Bogomolov-Gieseker type inequalities. Journal of algebraic geometry. 23 117–63
[47]
Schmidt, B (2017 ). Counterexample to the Generalized BogomolovGieseker Inequality for Threefolds. International mathematics research notices. 2017 2562–6
[48]
Bayer, A, Macrì, E and Stellari, P (2016 ). The space of stability conditions on abelian threefolds, and on some Calabi-Yau threefolds. Inventiones mathematicae. 206 869–933
[49]
Li, C (2018 ). Stability conditions on Fano threefolds of Picard number 1. Journal of the european mathematical society. 21 709–26
[50]
Li, C (2019 ). On stability conditions for the quintic threefold. Inventiones mathematicae. 218 301–40
[51]
Bayer, A and Macr`ı, E (2014 ). MMP for moduli of sheaves on K3s via wall-crossing: Nef and movable cones, Lagrangian fibrations. Inventiones mathematicae. 198 505–90
[52]
Bayer, A and Bridgeland, T (2017 ). Derived automorphism groups of K3 surfaces of Picard rank 1. Duke mathematical journal. Duke University Press. 166 75–124
[53]
Toda, Y (2013 ). Bogomolov-Gieseker-type inequality and counting invariants. Journal of topology. 6 217–50
[54]
Bayer, A, Bertram, A, Macrì, E and Toda, Y (2014 ). Bridgeland stability conditions on threefolds II: An application to Fujita’s conjecture. Journal of algebraic geometry. 23 693–710
[55]
Bayer, A and Macrì, E (2014 ). Projectivity and birational geometry of Bridgeland moduli spaces. Journal of the american mathematical society. 27 707–52
[56]
Bayer, A, Lahoz, M, Macrì, E, Nuer, H, Perry, A and Stellari, P (2021 ). Stability conditions in families. Publications mathématiques de l’ihés. 133 157–325
[57]
Bridgeland, T and Smith, I (2015 ). Quadratic differentials as stability conditions. Publications mathématiques de l’ihés. 121 155–278
[58]
Haiden, F, Katzarkov, L and Kontsevich, M (2017 ). Flat surfaces and stability structures. Publications mathématiques de l’ihés. 126 247–318
[59]
Haiden, F, Katzarkov, L and Simpson, C (2021 ). Spectral networks and stability conditions for Fukaya categories with coefficients. Arxiv:2112.13623 [math]. https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.13623